Home › Food and Drink › Bakery
The 10 Best Bakeries in Tacoma (2026)
This list ranks the 10 best bakeries in Tacoma based on Google review data, using a Bayesian-style score that balances average rating with number of reviews. Updated for 2026, the ranking highlights places that combine high customer satisfaction with a meaningful review sample rather than relying on raw averages alone. Tacoma’s bakery scene spans neighborhood corner shops, cake boutiques, and longtime delis, so whether you’re hunting for something everyday or a special-order option, this guide steers you toward businesses whose online reputations stand out locally.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a bakery in Tacoma?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Pro Blended Cookies
Pro Blended Cookies tops our list because it holds a perfect 5.0 Google rating with 181 reviews, giving it both an exemplary score and a substantial review base. That combination of a pristine average and solid review count pushes it above other highly rated contenders. As a Google-listed bakery in Tacoma, its ranking reflects consistent positive feedback from customers.
The full ranking
Eudora’s Bakery & Cafe
A bakery with a 4.9 rating based on 99 reviews, Eudora’s is listed on Google in Tacoma and ranks highly for its near-perfect average.
99 reviews
Lulu’s Bakery Shop
Lulu’s posts a 4.9 Google score from 94 reviews; the bakery shop’s rating sits among the city’s top-rated small bakeries.
94 reviews
Maggie Magee’s Bake Shop
With a 4.9 rating across 93 reviews, Maggie Magee’s Bake Shop is located in Fircrest and appears as a consistently well-reviewed bakery option.
93 reviews
Cakery Atelier
Cakery Atelier holds a 4.9 rating from 46 reviews and is listed on N Proctor Street, reflecting a strong average in that Proctor neighborhood.
46 reviews
Dragonfly Cakes
Classified as a cake shop, Dragonfly Cakes has a 4.9 rating from 27 Google reviews and is located on E 26th St in Tacoma.
27 reviews
Hess Bakery & Deli
Hess Bakery & Deli carries a 4.8 rating with a large review count of 1,887 and is located in Lakewood’s European Square, giving it wide local recognition.
1887 reviews
Howdy Bagel
Howdy Bagel is a Tacoma bakery with a 4.8 average from 881 Google reviews, combining a high score with extensive customer feedback.
881 reviews
Common Ground Coffee
Listed as a coffee shop, Common Ground Coffee has a 4.8 rating from 451 reviews and is located on Tacoma Ave S, reflecting strong local popularity.
451 reviews
Love by the Slice Baking & Catering Company
This Tacoma-listed bakery has a 4.8 rating based on 187 reviews and appears as a well-reviewed option for baking and catering needs.
187 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How do you choose a bakery for everyday treats versus a special order?
For everyday items, look for bakeries with steady positive reviews and frequent customers; they tend to have consistent quality and turnover. For special orders, prioritize bakeries with specific notes about custom cakes or catering in reviews, and contact them early to discuss your needs and availability.
What should I check in online reviews before visiting a bakery?
Scan reviews for recent comments about freshness, service, and accuracy of orders rather than isolated praise or complaints. Pay attention to multiple reviewers mentioning the same strengths or issues, and note how the business responds to feedback.
How much time should I allow when ordering a custom cake or large bakery order?
Custom and large orders typically require advance notice to ensure ingredients and scheduling; contact the bakery as soon as you know the event date. Ask about lead times, deposit policies, and any design or flavor consultations so there are no surprises close to the event.
How is this ranking of bakeries created?
The ranking is based on Google review data and uses a Bayesian-style approach that weights a business’s average rating by the number of reviews. That method favors places with both high scores and a meaningful volume of customer feedback rather than short-term or low-sample averages.