Home › Food and Drink › Butcher shop

Butcher shop in Tacoma

The 10 Best Butcher Shops in Tacoma (2026)

This list ranks the 10 best butcher shops as determined from Google reviews, using a Bayesian-style score that balances average rating with review volume. Updated for 2026, the guide highlights businesses customers praise most online and helps Tacoma-area shoppers find trusted places for meat and deli needs. Tacoma’s food scene includes everything from small neighborhood carnicerías to larger market counters, and online reviews offer a practical way to compare quality and consistency before you visit. We focused purely on Google review data and address information to assemble this local snapshot.

28 analyzed10 shortlisted4.8/5 average rating8,537 Google reviews

This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.

Are you a butcher shop in Tacoma?

People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.

✓ Live immediately  ·  ✓ One-time payment  ·  ✓ No subscription

10 of 10 spots still available

Our pick 2026

Stewart’s Meat Market

4.8/5 · 1581 Google reviews · 17821 WA-507, Yelm, WA 98597

Stewart’s Meat Market tops our list because it combines a very high Google rating (4.8) with a large number of reviews (1,581), which gives its score strong statistical weight. That combination of excellent average rating and extensive review volume is exactly what the ranking method rewards, so Stewart’s comes out on top for the Tacoma-area butcher category.

The full ranking

2

Blue Max Meats

9502 Canyon Rd E, Puyallup, WA 98371 · website

Blue Max Meats posts a 4.8 rating with 764 Google reviews and is listed as a Butcher shop at an address in Puyallup, WA.

4.8/5
764 reviews
3

Gibson’s Custom Meats

7912 Martin Way E, Olympia, WA 98516 · website

Gibson’s Custom Meats has a 4.8 Google score based on 508 reviews and appears as a Butcher shop located in Olympia, WA.

4.8/5
508 reviews
4

B & E Meats & Seafood

22501 Marine View Dr S #6841, Des Moines, WA 98198 · website

B & E Meats & Seafood is shown with a 4.8 rating from 466 reviews and is categorized as a Butcher shop at an address in Des Moines, WA.

4.8/5
466 reviews
5

The Live Butcher LLC

9432 16th Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98106 · website

The Live Butcher LLC holds a 4.8 rating supported by 210 Google reviews and is classified as a Butcher shop in Seattle, WA.

4.8/5
210 reviews
6

B & E Meat & Seafood

15003 Ambaum Blvd SW #1849, Burien, WA 98166 · website

B & E Meat & Seafood (Burien location) carries a 4.7 Google rating with 218 reviews and is listed as a Butcher shop in Burien, WA.

4.7/5
218 reviews
7

Doug The Butcher

8012 243rd St Ct E, Graham, WA 98338

Doug The Butcher shows a perfect 5.0 rating but with 11 reviews and is categorized as a Meat processor located in Graham, WA.

5/5
11 reviews
8

Tienda y Carniceria Palomino’s

804 E 56th St, Tacoma, WA 98404

Tienda y Carniceria Palomino’s has a 4.7 rating from 59 reviews, is categorized as a Butcher shop, and its address is in Tacoma’s 98404 area.

4.7/5
59 reviews
9

Metropolitan Market Tacoma

2420 N Proctor St, Tacoma, WA 98406 · website

Metropolitan Market Tacoma posts a 4.6 Google rating backed by 2,947 reviews and is listed as a Butcher shop at N Proctor St in Tacoma, WA.

4.6/5
2947 reviews
10

Tacoma Boys

901 39th Ave SW, Puyallup, WA 98373 · website

Tacoma Boys holds a 4.6 Google rating with 1,773 reviews and is categorized as a Produce market at an address in Puyallup, WA.

4.6/5
1773 reviews
Ranking built with our weighted score (Google rating × how reliable the review count is) across 28 businesses analyzed in Tacoma — our methodology.

Frequently asked questions

How did you determine which butcher shops are best?

We ranked businesses using their Google average rating weighted by review count (a Bayesian-style approach) so that high ratings with substantial review volume score higher than small-sample outliers. The list is based solely on publicly available Google review data and address information.

What should I look for when choosing a butcher shop?

Check recent reviews for consistency on quality, freshness, and customer service, verify the shop’s Google category and address, and look for details like sourcing transparency or preparation options if those matter to you. Visiting in person to inspect cleanliness and ask about cuts or custom orders is also helpful.

Are butcher shop prices the same across stores?

Prices vary by cut, supplier, and shop overhead; some places specialize in bulk or value cuts while others focus on specialty or custom processing. Expect to compare price per pound for specific cuts and ask directly about trimming, aging, or processing fees before committing.

When should I call a butcher ahead of time?

Call ahead if you need custom cuts, large quantities, specialty preparations, or to confirm availability of a specific cut. Calling also lets you reserve pick-up times and ask about lead times for processing whole or half animals.

Scroll to Top