Home › Business Services › Payroll service
The 10 Best Payroll Services in Tacoma (2026)
This list ranks the best payroll-related firms serving the Tacoma area using a review-weighted score derived from Google ratings, updated for 2026. We based the order on both average stars and the number of reviews so businesses with many strong opinions are favored over tiny samples. Tacoma’s mix of small businesses, nonprofits, and professional services means payroll needs vary from simple payroll runs to combined bookkeeping and tax preparation support, so the market includes traditional payroll shops and accounting firms offering payroll as part of broader services. Use this guide as a starting point to compare local options by rating and review volume.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a payroll service in Tacoma?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
253 Bookkeeping & Notary Solutions
253 Bookkeeping & Notary Solutions tops the list with a perfect 5.0 Google rating and 55 reviews, giving it both the highest score and a meaningful volume of customer feedback. Listed as a bookkeeping service and located in University Place, its combined high rating and review count are the main reasons it ranks first under our review-weighted method. The name also suggests bookkeeping and notary services that may appeal to small businesses seeking payroll-adjacent support.
The full ranking
Cascade Payroll
Listed as a payroll service with a perfect 5.0 rating across 23 reviews, Cascade Payroll is based at Pottery Ave in Port Orchard and ranks highly for its flawless average score and moderate review count.
23 reviews
Payroll Solutions Inc.
A payroll service showing a 5.0 Google rating from 17 reviews; the business is located on Oakesdale Ave SW in Renton and earns a top-tier score despite a smaller review sample.
17 reviews
Data Driven Decisions LLC
Categorized as an accounting firm, this company has a 5.0 rating with 16 reviews and operates out of East Side Dr NE in Tacoma, suggesting a local accounting option with excellent reviewer sentiment.
16 reviews
R & I Tax & Bookkeeping Service, Inc.
Listed as an accountant with a 4.9 Google rating from 29 reviews, R & I Tax & Bookkeeping is located on Pacific Ave in downtown Tacoma and combines strong ratings with a solid review base.
29 reviews
O&K Accounting
A bookkeeping service with a 5.0 rating from 11 reviews, O&K Accounting is based on 36th Ave Ct SW in Lakewood and appears as a smaller firm with top review marks.
11 reviews
Block Advisors
This tax preparation service carries a 4.8 Google rating built from 101 reviews and is located at Tacoma Mall Blvd; its large number of reviews gives it substantial presence in the market.
101 reviews
The Reynolds CPA Group
Listed as an accountant with a 4.8 rating from 60 reviews, The Reynolds CPA Group is on Broadway in Tacoma and combines professional accounting services with a strong review record.
60 reviews
Payroll NW
A payroll service showing a 4.8 rating across 26 reviews and located on NE 77th Ave in Vancouver; it appears here by virtue of solid ratings focused on payroll offerings.
26 reviews
McKinley Accounting Corporation
Categorized as a tax preparation service, McKinley Accounting Corporation holds a 4.6 Google rating from 11 reviews and is based on 93rd St E in Tacoma, representing a smaller, local tax-focused firm.
11 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose a payroll service for my small Tacoma business?
Start by listing your needs—payroll frequency, tax filing, direct deposit, and integrations with your accounting software. Compare provider reviews, responsiveness to questions, and whether they work with businesses of your size before requesting a proposal or demo.
What should I check before hiring a payroll or bookkeeping firm?
Verify their experience with payroll tax filing and worker classifications, ask about security measures for payroll data, and request references or sample reports. Confirm who will handle your account and how communication and problem resolution are managed.
How much does payroll service typically cost?
Costs vary by company, payroll frequency, number of employees, and add-on services like tax filing or timekeeping. Expect either per-paycheck fees, a monthly base plus per-employee charges, or bundled pricing; get written estimates to compare total costs.
How was this ranking of payroll services created?
The list is built from Google review data using a review-weighted score that favors both high average ratings and greater numbers of reviews. It reflects public ratings and review counts as of the 2026 update and is intended as a starting point for local comparison.