Home › Food and Drink › Italian restaurant
The 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Tacoma (2026)
This list ranks the top Italian restaurants connected to the Tacoma area using Google review data and a Bayesian scoring method that balances raw ratings with review volume. Updated for 2026, the roundup favors consistently high-rated places while reducing noise from very small sample sizes. Tacoma and its surrounding communities offer a mix of neighborhood trattorias, pizza spots, and fine-dining options, so this guide highlights dependable choices based on what local reviewers actually experienced. Use it as a starting point for reservations, takeout, or exploring familiar and nearby Italian-flavored dining options.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a italian restaurant in Tacoma?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
PortoVino Ristorante Italiano
PortoVino Ristorante Italiano comes out on top thanks to an outstanding 4.9 Google rating paired with 211 reviews, giving it a very strong Bayesian score. Its high average and solid review count push it above competitors that may have more reviews but slightly lower ratings. The result is a clear statistical edge that recognizes both quality and a meaningful sample of customer feedback.
The full ranking
Bacco Trattoria Italiana
Bacco Trattoria Italiana holds a 4.8 rating based on 780 Google reviews and is categorized as Italian, with an address on Martin Way E in Olympia, WA.
780 reviews
El Gaucho Tacoma
El Gaucho Tacoma appears with a 4.7 rating from 2,378 Google reviews and is classified as Steak; its address is on Pacific Ave in Tacoma, WA.
2378 reviews
Wooden City Tacoma
Wooden City Tacoma is rated 4.7 across 1,359 Google reviews and appears under the Restaurant category, located on Broadway in Tacoma, WA.
1359 reviews
Marzano Italian Restaurant
Marzano Italian Restaurant posts a 4.7 rating from 1,308 Google reviews and is listed as Italian; the address is on Garfield St S in Tacoma, WA.
1308 reviews
Over The Moon Cafe
Over The Moon Cafe has a 4.7 rating with 873 Google reviews and is categorized as Fine Dining, located on Opera Alley in Tacoma, WA.
873 reviews
Parky’s Pizza Bar
Parky’s Pizza Bar carries a 4.7 rating based on 192 Google reviews and shows up as a Restaurant; the address is on McKinley Ave in Tacoma, WA.
192 reviews
Il Lucano Ristorante Italiano
Il Lucano Ristorante Italiano holds a 4.6 rating with 1,479 Google reviews in the Italian category and is located on Judson St in Gig Harbor, WA.
1479 reviews
Manny’s Place
Manny’s Place is rated 4.6 from 622 Google reviews and is listed as a Restaurant, with an address on N 26th St in Tacoma, WA.
622 reviews
Cerello’s Pizza, Wine Cafe
Cerello’s Pizza, Wine Cafe posts a 4.6 rating based on 447 Google reviews and is categorized as Pizza, located on Center St in Tacoma, WA.
447 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How is this ranking determined?
The list is built from Google review data and uses a Bayesian-style score that balances average rating with the number of reviews. That approach reduces the impact of very small review counts while still rewarding consistently high ratings.
What should I check before choosing an Italian restaurant?
Look at recent reviews for clues about consistency, service, and any current menu or service changes. Also confirm hours, reservation policies, and whether they offer takeout or delivery if you need alternatives to dining in.
How much should I expect to spend at an Italian restaurant?
Prices vary widely depending on format—casual pizza spots and cafes tend to cost less than full-service trattorias or fine-dining establishments. Check menus online or call ahead to get a sense of portion sizes and price ranges for the specific place you plan to visit.
When is the best time to call or make a reservation?
Call or book ahead during peak dining times such as weekend evenings or around local events. For popular spots or larger groups, contacting the restaurant a few days in advance improves your chances of getting preferred times or accommodations.