Home › Shops and Services › Mortgage broker
The 10 Best Mortgage Brokers in Tacoma (2026)
This list ranks the best mortgage brokers serving the Tacoma area using a data-driven method: we base the ordering on Google reviews and apply a Bayesian-style weighting so both rating and review volume matter. Updated for 2026, the selection reflects which brokers and lenders have the strongest combination of high scores and meaningful customer feedback across Tacoma and nearby neighborhoods. Whether you’re shopping for your first mortgage or refinancing, this guide highlights local options that consistently earn five-star ratings and a significant number of reviews.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a mortgage broker in Tacoma?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation
Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation tops the list because it combines a perfect five-star average with the largest review count in our dataset (268 reviews), which gives it the strongest weighted score. As a Google-listed mortgage broker located on S 19th St in Tacoma, its high rating plus substantial customer feedback pushes it ahead of smaller but similarly rated firms. That blend of quality and volume is what put Fairway at number one in our 2026 ranking.
The full ranking
“Sean Werner | Mortgage Broker | VA, FHA & Conventional | PRMG | NMLS #388355”
This Gig Harbor-based Mortgage broker has a 5.0 rating with 245 reviews and is listed at Harborview Landing Shopping Ctr, 3226 Harborview Dr #1.
245 reviews
Will Smith – Vet2Vet Home Loan Team
Located in Puyallup at 13921 Meridian E Ste 201B, this Mortgage broker shows a perfect 5.0 rating backed by 111 Google reviews.
111 reviews
The Fornerette Team | Michael Fornerette
A Tacoma Mortgage broker at 5038 Tacoma Mall Blvd Ste C, it holds a 5.0 average from 101 reviews, indicating consistent high marks from clients.
101 reviews
Phil Zehr – Cross Country Mortgage
Listed as a Mortgage lender at 4717 S 19th St #102 in Tacoma, Phil Zehr has a 5.0 rating with 80 reviews on Google.
80 reviews
Eric Henning | Procura Mortgage a division of Alaska USA CU
Based in University Place (2607 Bridgeport Way W Ste 2M), this Mortgage broker carries a 5.0 score from 74 reviews.
74 reviews
Guild Mortgage – Amy Remington
A Guild Mortgage lender at 4301 S Pine St #540 in Tacoma, Amy Remington is rated 5.0 with 69 Google reviews.
69 reviews
Guild Mortgage – Kevin Day
Also a Guild Mortgage lender located at 4301 S Pine St Suites 540 & 110 in Tacoma, Kevin Day has a 5.0 rating across 50 reviews.
50 reviews
Rally Point Mortgage a dba of C2 Financial
Operating as a Mortgage broker at 231 Contra Costa Ave in Tacoma, Rally Point Mortgage holds a 5.0 average from 47 reviews.
47 reviews
Guild Mortgage – Lindsey Waldron
Listed at 4301 S Pine St Suites 540 & 110 in Tacoma, Lindsey Waldron is a Mortgage lender with a 5.0 rating based on 38 reviews.
38 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose the right mortgage broker for my situation?
Compare brokers on several factors: communicated loan programs, transparency about fees, responsiveness, and client reviews. Meet or speak with a few brokers to see who explains options clearly and matches the loan types you need.
What costs should I expect when working with a mortgage broker?
Brokers may charge a brokerage fee, or they might be paid by the lender; you should get a clear breakdown of origination fees, third‑party costs, and any broker commissions. Ask for a Good Faith Estimate or Loan Estimate early so you can compare total costs between offers.
What should I check on a broker before hiring them?
Verify their licensing (NMLS or state credentials), read multiple recent reviews, confirm the loan products they arrange, and ask for references if needed. Also ensure they disclose conflicts of interest and how they are compensated.
How was this ranking of mortgage brokers created?
The list is built from Google review data and ordered using a Bayesian-style score that weights both average rating and number of reviews, updated in 2026. It reflects which local firms combine high ratings with substantive customer feedback.